Recorded live at Feinstein's in March 2011. Includes songs from Fiddler on the Roof, She Loves Me, Fiorello! and rarely-heard songs from Harnick's early Off-Broadway career, film scores and unproduced musicals. Harnick joins Baldwin on several selections.
- 1. He Loves Me
- 2. "Good evening..."
- 3. The Boston Beguine
- 4. "What a daredevil..."
- 5. When Did I Fall in Love?
- 6. A Trip to the Library
- 7. "My favorite Sheldon Harnick show..."
- 8. Will He Like Me?
- 9. The Ballad of the Shape of Things
- 10. "Be kind to this Irish girl..."
- 11. Fiddler on the Roof Medley
- 12. To Life
- 13. If I Were a Rich Man
- 14. "Jerry Bock and I wrote a song..."
- 15. Dear Sweet Sewing Machine
- 16. "Cy Coleman and I had a meeting..."
- 17. You're Going Far
- 18. Gorgeous
- 19. "He drew from very personal images..."
- 20. I Couldn't Be with Anyone But You
- 21. "It's time to start saying goodnight..."
- 22. In My Own Lifetime
- 23. Sunrise, Sunset
